Concerns from published academic studies using the historical-critical method: common-link and isnad-cum-matn dating, anachronism, textual development, and legal or political context.
Each concern below is cited, was checked against its source before publication, and counts in the quality level of every hadith it applies to. Where a published response exists it is linked beside the concern.
22 concerns recorded so far, covering 8246 hadith. Most hadith have not yet been examined in this lens; their pages say so. Suggest a study by opening an issue.
Substantive · dated later by common-link analysis · Method: isnad-cum-matn analysis
Little (2022) argues that all versions of this hadith, including those whose chains do not pass through Hisham ibn 'Urwa, derive from a report Hisham first put into circulation in Kufah (Iraq) between 754 and 765 CE.
Joshua J. Little (2022) The Hadith of ʿĀʾišah's Marital Age: A Study in the Evolution of Early Islamic Historical Memory, DPhil thesis, University of Oxford (Pembroke College), pp. 2, 449, 472 (unabridged version 1.1). Source
No published response has been linked yet.
Chains of the 20 versions
All chains of the 20 versions drawn together from their automatic narrator matches: the source on the right,
the compilers' books on the left, one column per step of transmission. Thicker lines carry more chains. Narrators most versions pass through: عائشة بنت أبي بكر (16 of 20 versions); عروة بن الزبير بن (15 of 20 versions); هشام بن عروة بن (14 of 20 versions).
This shows the chains as matched; it is not the site's dating of the hadith.
Applies to 20 hadith
Applied to every version in the six books whose text states ʿĀʾišah's age at marriage or consummation. Little's analysis covers all versions of the marital-age hadith.
Minor · legal or political context · Method: matn criticism
Kister (1981) places the Prophet's invocation against Mudar in the context of his struggle with Quraysh, and argues that later factional disputes in the time of 'Ali and Mu'awiya changed how the invocation was understood.
M.J. Kister (1981) 'O God, Tighten Thy Grip on Mudar...': Some Socio-Economic and Religious Aspects of an Early Hadith, Journal of the Economic and Social History of the Orient 24/3 (1981), pp. 242-273, pp. 272-273. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
Kister does not question that the invocation goes back to the Prophet's time; the concern is only about later reinterpretation (the qunut practice), so severity should be minor at most.
Source text
“the changes which the perception of this invocation underwent in the Muslim community against the background of the Prophet's struggle with the unbelievers of Quraysh and of the later discussions between the factions of the nascent Muslim Empire at the time of 'Ali and Mu'awiya.”
“In later centuries it turned into a private supplication for guidance and success.”
No published response has been linked yet.
Chains of the 15 versions
All chains of the 15 versions drawn together from their automatic narrator matches: the source on the right,
the compilers' books on the left, one column per step of transmission. Thicker lines carry more chains. Narrators most versions pass through: أبو هريرة الدوسي الصحابي (14 of 15 versions); أبو سلمة بن عبد (5 of 15 versions); محمد بن مسلم بن (4 of 15 versions).
This shows the chains as matched; it is not the site's dating of the hadith.
Applies to 15 hadith
All 15 ids contain the invocation 'ushdud wat'ataka 'ala Mudar' (checked by text search; the search returned exactly these 15 and no others).
Substantive · wording varies across versions · Method: matn criticism
Kister (1984) argues that the short formula 'until they say la ilaha illa llah' is the earliest form, and that the versions adding the second shahada, prayer, zakat and other obligations reflect stipulations added during the first century of Islam; he also reports that classical scholars doubted the two-shahada version.
M.J. Kister (1984) '...Illa bi-haqqihi...': A Study of an Early Hadith, Jerusalem Studies in Arabic and Islam 5 (1984): 33-52, pp. 46, 49, 51. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
Applied only to the expanded versions. Kister calls the short formula the earliest form and says the further stipulations were added during the first century; under rubric v3 a study dating a substantive clause after the earliest form is 'later' for the versions carrying that clause. The p. 49 sentence reports classical scholars' doubts, not Kister's own verdict.
Source text
“the testimony of the prophethood of Muhammad was probably very shortly afterwards added to it. [...] it was supplemented by the addition of various stipulations and injunctions during the first century of Islam.”
“whereas the one which speaks of two shahadas and which mentions the obligations of the Muslim was subject to suspicion, its reliability being put to doubt.”
No published response has been linked yet.
Chains of the 11 versions
All chains of the 11 versions drawn together from their automatic narrator matches: the source on the right,
the compilers' books on the left, one column per step of transmission. Thicker lines carry more chains. Narrators most versions pass through: أنس بن مالك القشيري (5 of 11 versions); عبد الله بن المبارك (3 of 11 versions); واقد بن محمد بن (2 of 11 versions).
This shows the chains as matched; it is not the site's dating of the hadith.
Applies to 11 hadith
Expanded versions of 'umirtu an uqatila l-nas' that add the second shahada and/or obligations: Ibn 'Umar (bukhari-25, muslim-129: two shahadas, prayer, zakat); Abu Hurayra (muslim-126: two shahadas plus 'what I brought'; ibnmajah-71); Mu'adh (ibnmajah-72); Anas (bukhari-392, abudawud-2641, tirmidhi-2608, nasai-3967: prayer, qibla, slaughter); Anas versions of the Abu Bakr-'Umar exchange with prayer and zakat (nasai-3094, 3969).
Substantive · legal or political context · Method: matn criticism
Kister (1989) argues that the tradition that the Prophet prayed either in sandals or barefoot reflects a shift from the early injunction to pray in shoes towards free choice, and that it became widely circulated after the Prophet's death, during the conquests.
M.J. Kister (1989) 'Do Not Assimilate Yourselves...': La tashabbahu..., Jerusalem Studies in Arabic and Islam 12 (1989): 321-71, pp. 340, 344-345. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
'Widely circulated after the Prophet's death' is a claim about circulation, not invention; Kister ties it to post-conquest mosque floors (p. 344). The 'khalifu l-yahud' tradition gets the opposite, early dating (see split). Kister also reports that some doubted its soundness because of a transmitter (p. 345), which is a reported Sunni-lens view.
Source text
“The utterance became widely circulated in the period following the death of the Prophet, when the Arab tribes went on their huge conquest expeditions.”
“The change in the perception of the practice of prayer is evident: the believers were granted permission to pray as they wished, either barefoot or wearing shoes.”
No published response has been linked yet.
Applies to 2 hadith
Kister's n. 80 cites Ahmad (ed. Shakir) nos. 6627, 6660, i.e. 'Abdallah b. 'Amr's report. In our data that report ('I saw the Prophet pray barefoot and in sandals') is abudawud-653 and ibnmajah-1038 ('Amr b. Shu'ayb-his father-his grandfather). Shu'ayb chain but are about blood-money, drinking and turning after prayer, so I dropped them.
Minor · legal or political context · Method: matn criticism
Kister (1996) argues that the tradition about the three mosques gained almost unanimous approval only after the consolidation of Umayyad power, following earlier traditions that recommended travel only to Mecca, or to Mecca and Medina.
M.J. Kister (1996) Sanctity Joint and Divided: On Holy Places in the Islamic Tradition, Jerusalem Studies in Arabic and Islam 20 (1996): 18-65, pp. 18-19. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
Kister describes when the tradition was accepted and the extension from one to two to three mosques, without explicitly saying the three-mosque wording was created then. Read alongside his 1969 view that it is 'a very early one' (record 1). it is the same author's earlier study, not a response, so it is cross-referenced here instead.
Source text
“the consent of the Muslim orthodox scholars to grant validity to the famous utterance of the Prophet: "You shall set out only for the three mosques ...." was reached after a period of discussion among the scholars of Muslim law”
“Finally, after the consolidation of Umayyad power and the growth of the influence of Syria, the utterance concerning the three mosques quoted above gained almost unanimous approval.”
No published response has been linked yet.
Chains of the 14 versions
All chains of the 14 versions drawn together from their automatic narrator matches: the source on the right,
the compilers' books on the left, one column per step of transmission. Thicker lines carry more chains. Narrators most versions pass through: أبو هريرة الدوسي الصحابي (7 of 14 versions); قزعة بن يحيى البصري (6 of 14 versions); محمد بن مسلم بن (5 of 14 versions).
This shows the chains as matched; it is not the site's dating of the hadith.
Applies to 14 hadith
Same versions as record 1 (all 'thalathati masajid' versions in our data). Kister makes no chain-specific claim.
Serious · legal or political context · Method: matn criticism
Goldziher (1890) argues, citing al-Ya'qubi, that al-Zuhri was given the task of inventing and spreading the 'three mosques' saying to justify 'Abd al-Malik's politically motivated promotion of pilgrimage to the Dome of the Rock during Ibn al-Zubayr's control of Mecca.
I. Goldziher (1890) Muslim Studies vol. 2, ch. 2 (Umayyads and Abbasids), Muhammedanische Studien, vol. II (Halle: Max Niemeyer, 1890); English trans. Muslim Studies II, ed. S.M. Stern (London: George Allen & Unwin, 1971), German ed. pp. 35-36 and p. 37 n. 1. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
Goldziher's claim rests on al-Ya'qubi's report; Stern's English-edition note (not opened) reportedly calls that report an anti-Umayyad invention.
Source text
“Dem frommen Theologen Al-Zuhrî wurde die Aufgabe zu theil, die Berechtigung dieser durch politische Motive veranlassten Reform des religiösen Lebens durch die Erdichtung und Verbreitung eines auf den Propheten zurückgeführten Ausspruches zu erweisen”
“wonach es drei Moscheen gebe, zu welchen die Menschen wallfahrten mögen: die mekkanische, die medinensische und die in Jerusalem”
Chains of the 6 versions
All chains of the 6 versions drawn together from their automatic narrator matches: the source on the right,
the compilers' books on the left, one column per step of transmission. Thicker lines carry more chains. Narrators most versions pass through: محمد بن مسلم بن (5 of 6 versions); أبو هريرة الدوسي الصحابي (5 of 6 versions); سُفْيَانُ (3 of 6 versions).
This shows the chains as matched; it is not the site's dating of the hadith.
Applies to 6 hadith
Goldziher names the chain 'an al-Zuhri 'an Sa'id b. al-Musayyib 'an Abi Hurayra (p. 37 n. 1, citing Abu Dawud). Kept only versions whose chain carries al-Zuhri: bukhari-1189, muslim-3384, muslim-3385 (Ma'mar-Zuhri, 'bi-hadha l-isnad'), abudawud-2033, nasai-700, ibnmajah-1409. other non-Zuhri versions (e.g. bukhari-1197, bukhari-1864, muslim-3386) likewise excluded.
Serious · legal or political context · Method: matn criticism
Goldziher (1890) argues that the clause valuing a prayer in Jerusalem at a thousand prayers elsewhere belonged to the original, tendentious form of the three-mosques saying, and counts the Maymuna report on praying in Jerusalem among hadith that Syrians circulated in the Umayyad period to raise Jerusalem's status.
I. Goldziher (1890) Muslim Studies vol. 2, ch. 2 (Umayyads and Abbasids), Muhammedanische Studien, vol. II (Halle: Max Niemeyer, 1890); English trans. Muslim Studies II, ed. S.M. Stern (London: George Allen & Unwin, 1971), German ed. p. 36 and nn. 2, 6. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
he only says the Jerusalem clause was later 'neglected by levelling orthodoxy' in this and related sayings. Those ids should get no concern from this study.
Source text
“und ein Gebet im Bejt al-makdis von Jerusalem ist besser als tausend Gebete in anderen Heiligthümern”
“Aus dieser Parenthese ist die Tendenz des Hadith ersichtlich.”
No published response has been linked yet.
Applies to 2 hadith
He cites Ibn Maja p. 102 for the Jerusalem clause and quotes the Maymuna report ('the lands were at war then') from Abu Dawud I p. 48 (p. 37 n. 1). In our data: abudawud-457 (Maymuna, same wording incl.
Substantive · dated later by common-link analysis · Method: common-link analysis
Goldziher (1890) argues that the 'actions are judged by intentions' tradition was at first transmitted only in Medina, apparently spread there especially by the judge Yahya b. Sa'id al-Ansari (d. 143), and became a general legal principle only through later eclectic use of regional traditions.
I. Goldziher (1890) Muslim Studies vol. 2, ch. 6 (Talab al-hadith), Muhammedanische Studien, vol. II (Halle: Max Niemeyer, 1890); English trans. Muslim Studies II, ed. S.M. Stern (London: George Allen & Unwin, 1971), German ed. pp. 178-180 and p. 179 nn. 1, 5. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
Goldziher writes before common-link theory; he states the report was transmitted only in Medina in the older period and entered general circulation later, which dates its documented circulation after the Prophet's lifetime (rubric v3: 'later').
Source text
“Er wurde in älterer Zeit ausschliesslich in Medina überliefert”
“Erst durch den eklektischen Zug der Traditionsverwendung in der spätern Zeit ist er in das gemeine Hadith eingedrungen und ein maassgebender Grundsatz der muhammedanischen Rechtslehre geworden.”
No published response has been linked yet.
Chains of the 14 versions
All chains of the 14 versions drawn together from their automatic narrator matches: the source on the right,
the compilers' books on the left, one column per step of transmission. Thicker lines carry more chains. Narrators most versions pass through: محمد بن إبراهيم بن (12 of 14 versions); عمر بن الخطاب بن (12 of 14 versions); علقمة بن وقاص بتشديد (12 of 14 versions).
This shows the chains as matched; it is not the site's dating of the hadith.
Applies to 14 hadith
Goldziher names Yahya b. Sa'id al-Ansari as the apparent propagator in Medina (p. 179 n. 5). All 14 versions in our data carry the chain Yahya (b. Sa'id) - Muhammad b. Ibrahim - 'Alqama - 'Umar, so all are kept.
Serious · legal or political context · Method: matn criticism
Goldziher (1890) argues that a group of 'calming' hadith urging patience under unjust rulers owes its origin to the aim of securing obedience to the Umayyad government, and gives as an example the report in which the Prophet is made to tell a Companion to be patient until he meets him when later rulers take the booty for themselves.
I. Goldziher (1890) Muslim Studies vol. 2, ch. 3 (The hadith in its relation to the conflicts of the parties), Muhammedanische Studien, vol. II (Halle: Max Niemeyer, 1890); English trans. Muslim Studies II, ed. S.M. Stern (London: George Allen & Unwin, 1971), German ed. pp. 88, 93-94. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
Hudayr / Anas: 'you will meet with preference after me, so be patient until you meet me at the Pool': bukhari-3792, 3793, 7057, muslim-4779, tirmidhi-2189, nasai-5383) are a different report and are not discussed by Goldziher; they were dropped. Goldziher describes the whole group; he does not analyse this report's chain.
Source text
“eine Gruppe von politischen Hadithen ..., welche ihren Ursprung der Absicht verdankt, der Obrigkeit den Gehorsam des Volks unter Umständen zu sichern”
“Ich aber — entgegnet der Prophet — werde dir etwas anzeigen, was besser ist als dies: Harre aus, bis du mir wieder begegnest!”
No published response has been linked yet.
Applies to 1 hadith
Goldziher's example (rulers appropriating the booty; the Companion says he will take his sword on his shoulder; the Prophet answers 'be patient until you meet me') matches the Abu Dharr report abudawud-4759. He gives no source reference for it in the text.
Minor · legal or political context · Method: matn criticism
Goldziher (1890) presents al-Ahnaf b. Qays's report, in which Abu Bakra turns him back from joining 'Ali before the Battle of the Camel by citing this saying, as one of the historical examples quietist theologians cited to support their teaching that believers should stay out of civil strife.
I. Goldziher (1890) Muslim Studies vol. 2, ch. 3, Muhammedanische Studien, vol. II (Halle: Max Niemeyer, 1890); English trans. Muslim Studies II, ed. S.M. Stern (London: George Allen & Unwin, 1971), German ed. pp. 95-96 and p. 96 n. 1. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
Goldziher says the theologians 'cited' (anzuführen) such examples; unlike the general obedience hadith (p. 88), he does not say this report was invented or date it. 'development' (political use) is the cautious reading; a reviewer could read his framing as 'later'.
Source text
“Sie waren auch bemüht, für diese allgemeinen theoretischen Lehren praktische Beispiele aus der alten Geschichte des Islam anzuführen”
“Wenn zwei Muslime gegen einander das Schwert ziehen, so gelangen sie beide, der Mörder und der Ermordete, ins Höllenfeuer”
No published response has been linked yet.
Chains of the 7 versions
All chains of the 7 versions drawn together from their automatic narrator matches: the source on the right,
the compilers' books on the left, one column per step of transmission. Thicker lines carry more chains. Narrators most versions pass through: أيوب بن أبي تميمة (7 of 7 versions); حماد بن زيد بن (6 of 7 versions); الْحَسَنِ (5 of 7 versions).
This shows the chains as matched; it is not the site's dating of the hadith.
Applies to 7 hadith
Goldziher cites the al-Ahnaf - Abu Bakra narrative (B. Diyat nr. 2 = Fitan nr. 10). Kept only versions whose chain/text carries al-Ahnaf.
Substantive · legal or political context · Method: matn criticism
Goldziher (1890) uses the frame story of Marwan moving the 'Id sermon before the prayer as evidence of an Umayyad change to ritual, and places the saying 'whoever sees an evil, let him change it with his hand, tongue or heart' among the quietist traditions that theologians spread in the Umayyad period to calm believers under unjust rule.
I. Goldziher (1890) Muslim Studies vol. 2, ch. 2, Muhammedanische Studien, vol. II (Halle: Max Niemeyer, 1890); English trans. Muslim Studies II, ed. S.M. Stern (London: George Allen & Unwin, 1971), German ed. p. 43 n. 1; p. 95. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
Two different claims: he treats the Marwan frame story as historical evidence (not as invented), while he places the 'change evil ... in the heart' saying in the group of quietist traditions whose origin he links to Umayyad-era politics (p. 88). He does not discuss this saying's chain, so 'later' (not 'fabricated') is the cautious label.
Source text
“In diese Gruppe gehören die Traditionen, in welchen die Gläubigen ermahnt und getröstet werden, dass, wenn es nicht möglich ist, das herrschende Schlechte mit Hand und Zunge zu verändern, es genüge, im Herzen dagegen zu protestiren.”
“Nach einem Berichte bei Al-Tirmidi I, p. 105. II, p. 26 hat zuerst Merwän diese Veränderung eingeführt.”
No published response has been linked yet.
Chains of the 7 versions
All chains of the 7 versions drawn together from their automatic narrator matches: the source on the right,
the compilers' books on the left, one column per step of transmission. Thicker lines carry more chains. Narrators most versions pass through: قيس بن مسلم الجدلي (7 of 7 versions); طارق بن شهاب بن (7 of 7 versions); سعد بن مالك بن (5 of 7 versions).
This shows the chains as matched; it is not the site's dating of the hadith.
Applies to 7 hadith
Ids are all versions with the 'change it in his heart' wording; five of them (muslim-177, abudawud-1140, tirmidhi-2172, ibnmajah-1275, ibnmajah-4013) also carry the Marwan frame story Goldziher cites from al-Tirmidhi. He names no chain.
Minor · dated later by common-link analysis · Method: isnad-cum-matn analysis
Faghhizadeh and Dastranj (2025) find, by isnad-cum-matn analysis, that the 'Umar-Hisham b. Hakim (Surat al-Furqan) version of the seven-ahruf report has Ibn Shihab al-Zuhri as its main common link, place the narration by external dating in the Prophet's final years, and read it as concerning dialectal facilitation rather than the later seven canonical readings.
Abdolhadi Faghhizadeh; Fatemeh Dastranj (2025) Dating the Ḥadīth of 'Seven Aḥruf (Letters)' Based on the Combined Isnād-Text Analysis Method, Studies of Quran Reading (Muṭālaʿāt-i Qirāʾat-i Qurʾān) 13, no. 24 (2025): 7-42. doi:10.22034/qer.2025.18877.1261, pp. 7, 10 (English abstract); pp. 29-30, 36. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
The study identifies Ibn Shihab al-Zuhri (d. 124 AH) as the common link, so the documented circulation of these versions begins with him; the authors argue on other grounds that the report is older. Under rubric v3 this is recorded as a minor concern, with the authors' own dating stated in the summary.
Source text
“Most isnād networks lack a common core transmitter, except for reports describing the dispute between ʿUmar ibn al-Khaṭṭāb and Hishām ibn Ḥakīm over Sūrat al-Furqān, where Ibn Shihāb al-Zuhrī functions as the main common link”
“External dating situates these narrations in the final years of the Prophet's life.”
No published response has been linked yet.
Chains of the 13 versions
All chains of the 13 versions drawn together from their automatic narrator matches: the source on the right,
the compilers' books on the left, one column per step of transmission. Thicker lines carry more chains. Narrators most versions pass through: عمر بن الخطاب بن (9 of 13 versions); عروة بن الزبير بن (9 of 13 versions); هشام بن حكيم بن (8 of 13 versions).
This shows the chains as matched; it is not the site's dating of the hadith.
Applies to 13 hadith
The conclusion concerns the 'Umar-Hisham b. Hakim (Surat al-Furqan) reports with al-Zuhri as common link. muslim-1899 (Malik - Ibn Shihab, name split 'هشام بن، حكيم') and muslim-1901 (Ma'mar - al-Zuhri, 'with Yunus's isnad') added by reading Muslim 1899-1901.
Substantive · wording varies across versions · Method: isnad-cum-matn analysis
Kesgin (2014) judges that the clause 'evil omen is only in three things: woman, horse and house', found in three chains through Yunus b. Yazid al-Ayli, was very probably inserted into the text by mistake (idraj).
Salih Kesgin (2014) “(Hastalıkta) Bulaşıcılık Yoktur” Hadisinin İsnad ve Metin Açısından Tahlili [The Isnad and Matn Analysis of 'There is no contagion...' Hadith Narration], Hitit Üniversitesi İlahiyat Fakültesi Dergisi 13, no. 26 (2014/2): 83-120. doi:10.14395/jdiv260, pp. 96-97. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
Kesgin's main conclusion supports the 'no contagion' wording (recorded separately); this row covers only his judgment on the added clause.
Source text
“bu ifadenin hata ile hadis metnine dâhil edilmiş olma ihtimalinin çok yüksek olduğu ve bu haliyle hadis metninde idrâcin söz konusu olduğu kanaatine bizleri ulaştırmaktadır.”
No published response has been linked yet.
Chains of the 3 versions
All chains of the 3 versions drawn together from their automatic narrator matches: the source on the right,
the compilers' books on the left, one column per step of transmission. Thicker lines carry more chains. Narrators most versions pass through: يونس بن يزيد بن (3 of 3 versions); محمد بن مسلم بن (3 of 3 versions); عبد الله بن عمر (3 of 3 versions).
This shows the chains as matched; it is not the site's dating of the hadith.
Applies to 3 hadith
The three Yunus b. Yazid - al-Zuhri - Salim/Hamza - Ibn 'Umar versions Kesgin lists (p. 96).
Minor · legal or political context · Method: matn criticism
Hagemann (2014) reads the hadith 'Ali relates about the Kharijites in al-Baladhuri's account of Nahrawan as a device that, by appeal to the Prophet, lets 'Ali deny their status as Muslims, justifies killing them and foreshadows his own death as a martyr.
Hannah-Lena Hagemann (2014) History and Memory: Khārijism in Early Islamic Historiography, PhD thesis, University of Edinburgh, 2014 (Edinburgh Research Archive, hdl 1842/11692); revised as The Kharijites in Early Islamic Historical Tradition: Heroes and Villains (Edinburgh UP, 2021), pp. 95-96 and nn. 382, 385. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
Hagemann studies the hadith's literary function in 9th-10th-century chronicles and neither dates nor judges the hadith itself; 'development' only records the political-context reading. It may be better shown as context than as a concern on the six-book versions.
Source text
“with reference to the highest authority – the Prophet himself – it allows ʿAlī both to essentially claim that they forfeit their status as Muslims – pass through religion – due to their overzealous religiosity and to justify killing them”
“those sources which preserve a form of this ḥadīth emphasize that he was indeed among the dead at Nahrawān, confirming the validity of the Prophetic Tradition and ʿAlī's conduct towards them.”
No published response has been linked yet.
Chains of the 8 versions
All chains of the 8 versions drawn together from their automatic narrator matches: the source on the right,
the compilers' books on the left, one column per step of transmission. Thicker lines carry more chains. Narrators most versions pass through: سويد بن غفلة بفتح (6 of 8 versions); سليمان بن مهران الأسدي (6 of 8 versions); خيثمة بن عبد الرحمن (6 of 8 versions).
This shows the chains as matched; it is not the site's dating of the hadith.
Applies to 8 hadith
Hagemann analyses the historiographical (akhbar) versions in al-Baladhuri, al-Tabari and Ibn A'tham, not the isnads of the six books; she notes that versions 'abound in the hadith collections', citing Bukhari nos. 6930-6934 ('Attar edition) (p. 96 n. 385).
Substantive · wording varies across versions · Method: isnad-cum-matn analysis
Eich (2021) reports van Ess's finding that the idea that all deeds are predestined entered the unborn-predestination material at a later stage of transmission, and argues that the Ibn Mas'ud hadith is a later redactional addition to Ma'mar's Jami' and that the unborn topos was uncommon in the Qadar debate around 800.
Thomas Eich (2021) The Topos of the Unborn in Early Islamic Predestination Debates: A Study of the ḥadīṯ of Ḥuḏayfa Ibn Asīd in Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim, Rocznik Orientalistyczny 74, no. 1 (2021): 5-57. doi:10.24425/ro.2021.137245, pp. 5-6, 9-11, 35. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
The finding that the clause on deeds was added at a later stage is van Ess's (1975), as reported by Eich; Eich's own claim concerns the Ibn Mas'ud hadith as a later addition to Ma'mar's Jami'. Under rubric v3, a study dating a substantive clause later is 'later' for the versions carrying it.
Source text
“A major finding was that the idea that all human deeds are predestined and was only added at a later stage of the transmission of the ḥadīṯ material on the unborn predestination.”
“I consider the Ibn Masʿūd ḥadīṯ as a later addition to the Ǧāmiʿ and assume the lifetime of ʿAbd ar-Razzāq's pupil Isḥāq ad-Dabarī (d. 898/285) as the earliest safe date for this redaction process.”
No published response has been linked yet.
Chains of the 8 versions
All chains of the 8 versions drawn together from their automatic narrator matches: the source on the right,
the compilers' books on the left, one column per step of transmission. Thicker lines carry more chains. Narrators most versions pass through: سليمان بن مهران الأسدي (8 of 8 versions); زيد بن وهب الجهني (8 of 8 versions); عبد الله بن مسعود (4 of 8 versions).
This shows the chains as matched; it is not the site's dating of the hadith.
Applies to 8 hadith
Ids are the Ibn Mas'ud 'creation is gathered in the womb' versions. Eich's own isnad-cum-matn analysis is of the Hudhayfa b. Asid hadith (Muslim, Qadar), not of these.
Minor · dated later by common-link analysis · Method: common-link analysis
Akpınar (2013) reviews Juynboll's claim that Nafi' is only a seeming common link for the zakat al-fitr tradition and Motzki's reply that Nafi' is a real common link, agrees with Motzki, and adds further strands both had missed, increasing the documented Nafi' strands from 8 to 24.
Ömer Faruk Akpınar (2013) G.H.A. Juynboll'ün Nâfi' Hakkındaki İddialarına H. Motzki'nin Verdiği Yanıtın Değerlendirilmesi (An Evaluation of H. Motzki's Response about G.H.A. Juynboll's Claims on Nafi), Marife (Konya), Winter 2013, pp. 33-54, pp. 33, 39-46. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
The study identifies Nafi' (d. 117 AH) as the common link, so the documented circulation of these versions begins with him; the authors argue on other grounds that the report is older. Under rubric v3 this is recorded as a minor concern, with the authors' own dating stated in the summary.
Source text
“Nâfi’nin on bir râvîsinden sekizinin büyük ihtimalle ondan rivayeti sabit olup, Nâfî gerçek bir müşterek râvîdir.”
“Nâfi-İbn Ömer hadis isnadlarının Juynboll’ün iddia ettiği gibi Mâlik’e değil, bizzat Nâfi’ye dayandığı, Nâfi’nin gerçek müşterek râvî olduğu sonucuna varır.”
No published response has been linked yet.
Chains of the 23 versions
All chains of the 23 versions drawn together from their automatic narrator matches: the source on the right,
the compilers' books on the left, one column per step of transmission. Thicker lines carry more chains. Narrators most versions pass through: عبد الله بن عمر (18 of 23 versions); نافع أبو عبد الله (14 of 23 versions); مالك بن أنس بن (5 of 23 versions).
This shows the chains as matched; it is not the site's dating of the hadith.
Applies to 23 hadith
The study concerns the Nafi' - Ibn 'Umar zakat al-fitr tradition. Ids are versions whose chain runs through Nafi' to Ibn 'Umar with the fitr amount (script over our data: chain has نافع + ابن عمر/عبد الله بن عمر, text has الفطر and صاع; plus bukhari-1507, muslim-2280, nasai-2500 read directly). Ibn 'Abbas: nasai-2509; 'Ammar b. Sa'd: ibnmajah-1830). The 'pay before the prayer' Nafi' versions (e.g. bukhari-1509) are not included.
Minor · originating narrator criticised
Goldziher (1890) cites Ibn ʿUmar's reported remark that Abu Hurayra had a personal interest (farmland) in a wording he transmitted, and states that Abu Hurayra was regarded in early times as an authority not fully worth heeding.
Ignaz Goldziher (1890) Muhammedanische Studien, Zweiter Theil, Halle a. S.: Max Niemeyer, p. 49 and n. 4. Source
This assessment concerns Abu Hurayra, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 3,908 reports whose chains all start from Abu Hurayra. All assessments of Abu Hurayra.
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Source text
“Man berichtete dem Sohne ʿOmar's, dass Abū Hurejra auch folgende Worte tradirt: und mit Ausnahme der Feldhunde. Da sagt der Sohn ʿOmar's: Abū Hurejra hat Saatfelder”
“Diese Bemerkung des Ibn ʿOmar ist recht bezeichnend für die Zumuthungen, die man an die bona fides der Ueberlieferer schon in der ältesten Periode der Traditionsbildung stellte.”
“dass man in der ältern Zeit Abū Hurejra (…) als eine nicht recht beachtenswerthe Autorität betrachtete.”
No published response has been linked yet.
Applies to 3,908 hadith
Applied to every report whose chains all start from Abu Hurayra (3,908 reports), identified by the name at the head of each chain.
Minor · originating narrator criticised
Goldziher (1884) reports that jurists often set aside Abu Hurayra's legal traditions, cites a statement ascribed to Abu Hanifa excluding Abu Hurayra's opinion, and notes a passage in al-Azraqi showing that some thought him capable of false reports.
Ignaz Goldziher (1884) Die Ẓâhiriten: ihr Lehrsystem und ihre Geschichte, Leipzig: Otto Schulze, pp. 78-79. Source
This assessment concerns Abu Hurayra, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 3,908 reports whose chains all start from Abu Hurayra. All assessments of Abu Hurayra.
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Source text
“dass Traditionen Abu Hurejra's, selbst solche, die in die kanonischen Sammlungen aufgenommen sind, von den Rechtsgelehrten als Autoritäten für die Rechtsentscheidung oft verworfen werden”
“mit Ausnahme des Abu Hurejra, Anas b. Mālik und Samura b. Gundab”
“aus welcher hervorgeht, dass man den Abu Hurejra lügenhafter Nachrichten für fähig hielt.”
No published response has been linked yet.
Applies to 3,908 hadith
Applied to every report whose chains all start from Abu Hurayra (3,908 reports), identified by the name at the head of each chain.
Substantive · originating narrator criticised
Sprenger (1865) argues that Abu Hurayra invented most of the reports he related, reading his explanation of his prolific transmission as an admission.
Aloys Sprenger (1865) Das Leben und die Lehre des Moḥammad, Bd. 3 (Einleitung on the sources), Berlin: Nicolai, pp. LXXXIII-LXXXV. Source
This assessment concerns Abu Hurayra, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 3,908 reports whose chains all start from Abu Hurayra. All assessments of Abu Hurayra.
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Source text
“erwähne ich den in A. H. 58 verstorbenen Abü Horayra, doch mit dem Bemerken, dafs ich ihn nicht als den Repräsentanten seiner Zeit in der Traditionswissenschaft ansehe, denn er war ein Extrem von frommem Betrug.”
“Da wir nicht von dem starken Glauben der Schüler des Abü Horayra beseelt sind, halten wir solche Erklärungen für Bekenntnisse, dafs er die meisten Nachrichten erfunden habe.”
“Wie hat sich die moslimische Gemeinde solchen Lügnern wie Abü Horayra und Ibn ʿAbbâs (und solche hat es viele gegeben) gegenüber benommen?”
Applies to 3,908 hadith
Applied to every report whose chains all start from Abu Hurayra (3,908 reports), identified by the name at the head of each chain.
Substantive · originating narrator criticised
Sprenger (1865) groups Ibn ʿAbbas with Abu Hurayra as Companions who, in his view, related untrue reports.
Aloys Sprenger (1865) Das Leben und die Lehre des Moḥammad, Bd. 3 (Einleitung on the sources), Berlin: Nicolai, p. LXXXV. Source
This assessment concerns Ibn 'Abbas, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 1,843 reports whose chains all start from Ibn 'Abbas. All assessments of Ibn 'Abbas.
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Source text
“Wie hat sich die moslimische Gemeinde solchen Lügnern wie Abü Horayra und Ibn ʿAbbâs (und solche hat es viele gegeben) gegenüber benommen?”
No published response has been linked yet.
Applies to 1,843 hadith
Applied to every report whose chains all start from Ibn 'Abbas (1,843 reports), identified by the name at the head of each chain.
Minor · originating narrator criticised
Goldziher (1890) notes that later critics did not fully accept ʿAmr b. Shuʿayb's transmissions from his great-grandfather's sahifa. He observes that only about 45 of the 700 traditions ascribed to ʿAbd Allah b. ʿAmr appear in the two Sahihs, and he regards these as at least formally tolerable.
Ignaz Goldziher (1890) Muhammedanische Studien, Zweiter Theil, Halle a. S.: Max Niemeyer, pp. 10, 195 n. 3. Source
This assessment concerns 'Abd Allah b. 'Amr b. al-'As, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 312 reports whose chains all start from 'Abd Allah b. 'Amr b. al-'As. All assessments of 'Abd Allah b. 'Amr b. al-'As.
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Source text
“Dies wird die Sahifa sein, aus welcher sein Urenkel ʿAmr b. Shuʿejb (st. 120) sein Traditionsmaterial überlieferte, und aus diesem Grunde haben spätere Kritiker seine auf den Urgrossvater zurückgeführten Traditionsdaten nicht als vollgültig anerkannt.”
“Man hat auf ihn insgesammt 700 Traditionen zurückgeführt, von denselben finden sich in beiden Sahihen nur 17, bei B. allein 8, bei M. allein 20, also von 700 Traditionen höchstens 45 von einigermaassen — wenn auch nur formell — erträglicher Glaubwürdigkeit.”
No published response has been linked yet.
Applies to 312 hadith
Applied to every report whose chains all start from 'Abd Allah b. 'Amr b. al-'As (312 reports), identified by the name at the head of each chain.
Minor · originating narrator criticised
Goldziher (1884) cites a dialogue ascribed to Abu Hanifa in which he would set aside his own opinion for any Companion's view except those of Abu Hurayra, Anas b. Malik and Samura b. Jundab.
Ignaz Goldziher (1884) Die Ẓâhiriten: ihr Lehrsystem und ihre Geschichte, Leipzig: Otto Schulze, p. 79. Source
This assessment concerns Anas b. Malik, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 2,063 reports whose chains all start from Anas b. Malik. All assessments of Anas b. Malik.
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Source text
“mit Ausnahme des Abu Hurejra, Anas b. Mālik und Samura b. Gundab”
No published response has been linked yet.
Applies to 2,063 hadith
Applied to every report whose chains all start from Anas b. Malik (2,063 reports), identified by the name at the head of each chain.