Hadith Explorer الكتب الستة

People reports start from

Cited assessments of the Companions and others at the head of a report's chain, from Sunni, Shia and historical-critical sources. Each is applied to every report whose chains all start from that person. Severity follows a fixed rule: a source that rejects the person as a narrator gives a substantive concern; criticism short of rejection gives a minor one (Method). The site reports these views; it does not endorse them, and published defences are linked beside them.

Abu Hurayra

3,908 reports start from Abu Hurayra in the six books. Name forms used to identify them at the head of a chain: ابا هريره، ابو هريره، ابي هريره

Sunni hadith criticism

Minor · originating narrator criticised · Method: rijal assessment

al-Nawawi (Sharh Muslim), commenting on Muslim's report, records that people in Abu Hurayra's time said he narrated too much.

al-Nawawi (d. 676 AH) (1392 AH) al-Minhaj Sharh Sahih Muslim b. al-Hajjaj, Beirut: Dar Ihya' al-Turath al-'Arabi, 2nd ed.; text from the OpenITI corpus, p. 16/53. Source

This assessment concerns Abu Hurayra, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 3,908 reports whose chains all start from Abu Hurayra. All assessments of Abu Hurayra.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Commentary on the chapter on the merits of Abu Hurayra (Muslim no. 2492), where Abu Hurayra answers those who said he narrated too much.

Source text

قوله (يقولون إن أبا هريرة يكثر الحديث والله الموعد معناه فيحاسبني إن تعمدت كذبا

al-Minhaj Sharh Sahih Muslim b. al-Hajjaj, p. 16/53 · source text
Published responses
  • al-Nawawi (d. 676 AH), al-Minhaj Sharh Sahih Muslim b. al-Hajjaj, p. 16/54: In the report, Abu Hurayra answers that God will judge him if he lied and will judge those who thought badly of him, and explains that he stayed close to the Prophet while others were busy trading in the markets; al-Nawawi explains these words.

    معناه فيحاسبني إن تعمدت كذبا ويحاسب من ظن بي السوء

    al-Minhaj Sharh Sahih Muslim b. al-Hajjaj, p. 16/54 · source text

Shia hadith criticism

Substantive · narrator rejected in Shia assessment · Method: rijal assessment

al-Najmi (Adwa' 'ala al-Sahihayn) states that Abu Hurayra was among Mu'awiya's circle who produced hadith, and that he was accused in his own time of lying and of narrating too much.

Muhammad Sadiq al-Najmi (n.d.) Adwa' 'ala al-Sahihayn, text from the OpenITI corpus (Zaydiyya0000454); pages as in that text, p. 100. Source

This assessment concerns Abu Hurayra, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 3,908 reports whose chains all start from Abu Hurayra. All assessments of Abu Hurayra.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Chapter 4 ('Evidence for the weakness of the Two Sahihs'), section 'Assessing the faith of some narrators of the Two Sahihs', where the author profiles narrators from whom al-Bukhari and Muslim took many reports.

Source text

كان ابو هريرة من اعوان معاوية واصحابه ومن اعضا مؤسسته لوضع الحديث، وهو من جملة اولئك الذين رووا المطاعن في الامام على (ع) واهل بيته (ع)، وحكوا الفضائل والمناقب لمعاوية والخلفاء الثلاثة(2). وكان ابو هريرة من الذين اتهموا في زمانه بالكذب واكثار الحديث،

No published response has been linked yet.

Substantive · narrator rejected in Shia assessment · Method: rijal assessment

Hashim Ma'ruf al-Hasani (Dirasat fi al-Hadith wa-l-Muhaddithin) argues that early Companions saw Abu Hurayra as a danger to the Sunna because he took material from Ka'b al-Ahbar and others and attributed it to the Prophet; he goes on to cite reports that 'Umar, 'Ali and others called him a liar.

Hashim Ma'ruf al-Hasani (d. 1403 AH) (1398 AH) Dirasat fi al-Hadith wa-l-Muhaddithin, Beirut: Dar al-Ta'aruf li-l-Matbu'at; text from the OpenITI corpus, p. 94. Source

This assessment concerns Abu Hurayra, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 3,908 reports whose chains all start from Abu Hurayra. All assessments of Abu Hurayra.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Chapter 3 ('On the Companions'), section 'The probity of the Companions' ('Adalat al-sahaba), arguing against the doctrine that all Companions are trustworthy narrators.

Source text

ولقد عرفه الصحابة الاولون وادركوا خطره على السنة الكريمة من خلال مروياته التي كان يتلقاها من كعب الاحبار وغيره ويسندها إلى الرسول (ص)

Dirasat fi al-Hadith wa-l-Muhaddithin, p. 94 · source text

No published response has been linked yet.

Substantive · narrator rejected in Shia assessment · Method: rijal assessment

Khulasat 'Abaqat al-Anwar (Mir Hamid Husayn, abridged) states that 'Umar called Abu Hurayra a liar, held him suspect, struck him and threatened to expel him, and goes on to cite reports that 'Uthman, 'Ali, 'A'isha and al-Zubayr also disputed his reports.

Mir Hamid Husayn al-Lakhnawi (d. 1306 AH), abridged (1405 AH) Khulasat 'Abaqat al-Anwar, text from the OpenITI corpus (Shia001555), p. 3/245. Source

This assessment concerns Abu Hurayra, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 3,908 reports whose chains all start from Abu Hurayra. All assessments of Abu Hurayra.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Vol. 3, 'Rare episodes from the lives of the Companions', refuting al-Muzani's reading of the hadith 'my Companions are like the stars' (that every Companion is trustworthy in what he transmits); the author lists Companions whom other Companions called liars or held suspect.

Source text

أبو هريرة لقد كذب عمر بن الخطاب أبا هريرة واتهمه وأنكر عليه، حتى ضربه بالدرة وهدده بإخراجه من المدينة المنورة..

No published response has been linked yet.

Substantive · narrator rejected in Shia assessment · Method: rijal assessment

Murtada al-'Askari (Ma'alim al-Madrasatayn) states that Abu Hurayra, with 'Amr b. al-'As and Samura b. Jundab, produced hadith to support Mu'awiya and narrated it from the Prophet.

Murtada al-'Askari (d. 1428 AH) (1410 AH / 1990) Ma'alim al-Madrasatayn, text from the OpenITI corpus (Shia001663), p. 2/52. Source

This assessment concerns Abu Hurayra, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 3,908 reports whose chains all start from Abu Hurayra. All assessments of Abu Hurayra.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Vol. 2, on the influences that shaped the 'school of the caliphs' from Mu'awiya's time; followed by al-Mada'ini's account of Mu'awiya's letters to his governors.

Source text

فاستمد في هذا السبيل من بعض بقايا الصحابة ممن كان في دينه رقة، وفي نفسه ضعف من أمثال عمرو بن العاص، وسمرة بن جندب 1، وأبي هريرة. فاستجابوا له ووضعوا له من الحديث ما يساعده، ثم رووه عن رسول الله (ص).

No published response has been linked yet.

Substantive · narrator rejected in Shia assessment · Method: rijal assessment

Sharaf al-Din (al-Nass wa-l-Ijtihad), quoting Abu Ja'far al-Iskafi via Ibn Abi al-Hadid, reports that Mu'awiya paid some Companions and Successors to narrate reports against 'Ali and that Abu Hurayra was among them (with 'Amr b. al-'As, al-Mughira b. Shu'ba and 'Urwa b. al-Zubayr).

'Abd al-Husayn Sharaf al-Din (d. 1377 AH) (n.d.) al-Nass wa-l-Ijtihad, ed. Abu Mujtaba; text from the OpenITI corpus (Zaydiyya0000161); pages as in that text, p. 509. Source

This assessment concerns Abu Hurayra, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 3,908 reports whose chains all start from Abu Hurayra. All assessments of Abu Hurayra.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Section on Mu'awiya's measures against 'Ali; the view relayed is al-Iskafi's.

Source text

منه، وجعل لهم على ذلك جعلا يرغب في مثله، فاختلقوا له ما أرضاه. (قال): منهم أبو هريرة (788)

No published response has been linked yet.

Minor · originating narrator criticised · Method: rijal assessment

Hashim Ma'ruf al-Hasani (Dirasat fi al-Hadith wa-l-Muhaddithin), citing Ibn Qutayba and a report from Shu'ba via al-Dhahabi, says Abu Hurayra was known for tadlis (citing the Prophet for what he heard from others).

Hashim Ma'ruf al-Hasani (d. 1403 AH) (1398 AH) Dirasat fi al-Hadith wa-l-Muhaddithin, Beirut: Dar al-Ta'aruf li-l-Matbu'at; text from the OpenITI corpus, p. 166. Source

This assessment concerns Abu Hurayra, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 3,908 reports whose chains all start from Abu Hurayra. All assessments of Abu Hurayra.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Chapter 5, section 'From the men of al-Bukhari', which reviews narrators in Sahih al-Bukhari who were criticised. Discussion of tadlis among al-Bukhari's narrators.

Source text

وممن اشتهر بالتدليس أبو هريرة الذي اعتمد عليه البخاري اكثر من جميع الصحابة. قال ابن قتيبة في تأويل مختلف الحديث كان أبو هريرة يقول قال رسول الله (ص) كذا وانما سمعه من غيره

Dirasat fi al-Hadith wa-l-Muhaddithin, p. 166 · source text

No published response has been linked yet.

Historical-critical method

Substantive · originating narrator criticised

Sprenger (1865) argues that Abu Hurayra invented most of the reports he related, reading his explanation of his prolific transmission as an admission.

Aloys Sprenger (1865) Das Leben und die Lehre des Moḥammad, Bd. 3 (Einleitung on the sources), Berlin: Nicolai, pp. LXXXIII-LXXXV. Source

This assessment concerns Abu Hurayra, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 3,908 reports whose chains all start from Abu Hurayra. All assessments of Abu Hurayra.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Source text

“erwähne ich den in A. H. 58 verstorbenen Abü Horayra, doch mit dem Bemerken, dafs ich ihn nicht als den Repräsentanten seiner Zeit in der Traditionswissenschaft ansehe, denn er war ein Extrem von frommem Betrug.”

p. LXXXIII

“Da wir nicht von dem starken Glauben der Schüler des Abü Horayra beseelt sind, halten wir solche Erklärungen für Bekenntnisse, dafs er die meisten Nachrichten erfunden habe.”

p. LXXXIV

“Wie hat sich die moslimische Gemeinde solchen Lügnern wie Abü Horayra und Ibn ʿAbbâs (und solche hat es viele gegeben) gegenüber benommen?”

p. LXXXV
Published responses

Minor · originating narrator criticised

Goldziher (1890) cites Ibn ʿUmar's reported remark that Abu Hurayra had a personal interest (farmland) in a wording he transmitted, and states that Abu Hurayra was regarded in early times as an authority not fully worth heeding.

Ignaz Goldziher (1890) Muhammedanische Studien, Zweiter Theil, Halle a. S.: Max Niemeyer, p. 49 and n. 4. Source

This assessment concerns Abu Hurayra, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 3,908 reports whose chains all start from Abu Hurayra. All assessments of Abu Hurayra.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Source text

“Man berichtete dem Sohne ʿOmar's, dass Abū Hurejra auch folgende Worte tradirt: und mit Ausnahme der Feldhunde. Da sagt der Sohn ʿOmar's: Abū Hurejra hat Saatfelder”

p. 49

“Diese Bemerkung des Ibn ʿOmar ist recht bezeichnend für die Zumuthungen, die man an die bona fides der Ueberlieferer schon in der ältesten Periode der Traditionsbildung stellte.”

p. 49

“dass man in der ältern Zeit Abū Hurejra (…) als eine nicht recht beachtenswerthe Autorität betrachtete.”

p. 49 n. 4

No published response has been linked yet.

Minor · originating narrator criticised

Goldziher (1884) reports that jurists often set aside Abu Hurayra's legal traditions, cites a statement ascribed to Abu Hanifa excluding Abu Hurayra's opinion, and notes a passage in al-Azraqi showing that some thought him capable of false reports.

Ignaz Goldziher (1884) Die Ẓâhiriten: ihr Lehrsystem und ihre Geschichte, Leipzig: Otto Schulze, pp. 78-79. Source

This assessment concerns Abu Hurayra, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 3,908 reports whose chains all start from Abu Hurayra. All assessments of Abu Hurayra.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Source text

“dass Traditionen Abu Hurejra's, selbst solche, die in die kanonischen Sammlungen aufgenommen sind, von den Rechtsgelehrten als Autoritäten für die Rechtsentscheidung oft verworfen werden”

p. 78

“mit Ausnahme des Abu Hurejra, Anas b. Mālik und Samura b. Gundab”

p. 79

“aus welcher hervorgeht, dass man den Abu Hurejra lügenhafter Nachrichten für fähig hielt.”

p. 79

No published response has been linked yet.

'A'isha

2,191 reports start from 'A'isha in the six books. Name forms used to identify them at the head of a chain: عايشه، عايشه ام المومنين

Shia hadith criticism

Minor · originating narrator criticised · Method: rijal assessment

Murtada al-'Askari (Ahadith Umm al-Mu'minin 'A'isha) argues that 'A'isha used accounts of the Prophet's life to serve her positions in the politics of her time, so her many reports need critical study to separate sound from unsound.

Murtada al-'Askari (d. 1428 AH) (1414 AH / 1994) Ahadith Umm al-Mu'minin 'A'isha, 5th ed.; text from the OpenITI corpus (Shia001626), p. 2/12. Source

This assessment concerns 'A'isha, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 2,191 reports whose chains all start from 'A'isha. All assessments of 'A'isha.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Vol. 2 introduction, explaining why the author undertakes a critical study of the large body of hadith narrated from 'A'isha.

Source text

والمهم في ذلك الأمر كله أننا وجدنا خلال دراساتنا في الحديث والتاريخ أن أم المؤمنين عائشة كانت تعتمد حياة الرسول (ص) لكل ما تريد.

Ahadith Umm al-Mu'minin 'A'isha, p. 2/12 · source text

No published response has been linked yet.

Anas b. Malik

2,063 reports start from Anas b. Malik in the six books. Name forms used to identify them at the head of a chain: انس، انس بن مالك، انسا

Shia hadith criticism

Minor · originating narrator criticised · Method: rijal assessment

Khulasat 'Abaqat al-Anwar states that Anas b. Malik lied in the episode of the roasted bird (Hadith al-Tayr) and concealed testimony about Ghadir when asked by 'Ali.

Mir Hamid Husayn al-Lakhnawi (d. 1306 AH), abridged (1405 AH) Khulasat 'Abaqat al-Anwar, text from the OpenITI corpus (Shia001555), p. 3/258. Source

This assessment concerns Anas b. Malik, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 2,063 reports whose chains all start from Anas b. Malik. All assessments of Anas b. Malik.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Vol. 3, 'Rare episodes from the lives of the Companions', refuting al-Muzani's reading of the hadith 'my Companions are like the stars' (that every Companion is trustworthy in what he transmits); the author lists Companions whom other Companions called liars or held suspect.

Source text

أنس بن مالك لقد كذب أنس بن مالك في قضية الطير المشوي، كما هو ظاهر كل الظهور على من راجع مجلد (حديث الطير) من كتابنا.

No published response has been linked yet.

Historical-critical method

Minor · originating narrator criticised

Goldziher (1884) cites a dialogue ascribed to Abu Hanifa in which he would set aside his own opinion for any Companion's view except those of Abu Hurayra, Anas b. Malik and Samura b. Jundab.

Ignaz Goldziher (1884) Die Ẓâhiriten: ihr Lehrsystem und ihre Geschichte, Leipzig: Otto Schulze, p. 79. Source

This assessment concerns Anas b. Malik, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 2,063 reports whose chains all start from Anas b. Malik. All assessments of Anas b. Malik.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Source text

“mit Ausnahme des Abu Hurejra, Anas b. Mālik und Samura b. Gundab”

p. 79

No published response has been linked yet.

Ibn 'Abbas

1,843 reports start from Ibn 'Abbas in the six books. Name forms used to identify them at the head of a chain: ابن عباس، عبد الله بن عباس

Historical-critical method

Substantive · originating narrator criticised

Sprenger (1865) groups Ibn ʿAbbas with Abu Hurayra as Companions who, in his view, related untrue reports.

Aloys Sprenger (1865) Das Leben und die Lehre des Moḥammad, Bd. 3 (Einleitung on the sources), Berlin: Nicolai, p. LXXXV. Source

This assessment concerns Ibn 'Abbas, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 1,843 reports whose chains all start from Ibn 'Abbas. All assessments of Ibn 'Abbas.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Source text

“Wie hat sich die moslimische Gemeinde solchen Lügnern wie Abü Horayra und Ibn ʿAbbâs (und solche hat es viele gegeben) gegenüber benommen?”

p. LXXXV

No published response has been linked yet.

'Abd Allah b. 'Amr b. al-'As

312 reports start from 'Abd Allah b. 'Amr b. al-'As in the six books. Name forms used to identify them at the head of a chain: عبد الله بن عمرو، عبد الله بن عمرو بن العاص

Shia hadith criticism

Minor · originating narrator criticised · Method: rijal assessment

Hashim Ma'ruf al-Hasani (Dirasat fi al-Hadith wa-l-Muhaddithin) says Ka'b al-Ahbar and Wahb b. Munabbih were a major source for Abu Hurayra and 'Abd Allah b. 'Amr b. al-'As.

Hashim Ma'ruf al-Hasani (d. 1403 AH) (1398 AH) Dirasat fi al-Hadith wa-l-Muhaddithin, Beirut: Dar al-Ta'aruf li-l-Matbu'at; text from the OpenITI corpus, p. 91. Source

This assessment concerns 'Abd Allah b. 'Amr b. al-'As, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 312 reports whose chains all start from 'Abd Allah b. 'Amr b. al-'As. All assessments of 'Abd Allah b. 'Amr b. al-'As.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Chapter 3 ('On the Companions'), section 'The probity of the Companions' ('Adalat al-sahaba), arguing against the doctrine that all Companions are trustworthy narrators.

Source text

وبينهم امثال كعب الاحبار ووهب بن منبه وغيرهما ممن كانوا يزودون بعض الصحابة بمقنرياتهم التي تسئ إلى الاسلام والسنة الكريمة وكان هؤلاء مصدرا ضخما لابي هريرة وعبد الله بن عمرو بن العاص وامثالهما.

Dirasat fi al-Hadith wa-l-Muhaddithin, p. 91 · source text

No published response has been linked yet.

Historical-critical method

Minor · originating narrator criticised

Goldziher (1890) notes that later critics did not fully accept ʿAmr b. Shuʿayb's transmissions from his great-grandfather's sahifa. He observes that only about 45 of the 700 traditions ascribed to ʿAbd Allah b. ʿAmr appear in the two Sahihs, and he regards these as at least formally tolerable.

Ignaz Goldziher (1890) Muhammedanische Studien, Zweiter Theil, Halle a. S.: Max Niemeyer, pp. 10, 195 n. 3. Source

This assessment concerns 'Abd Allah b. 'Amr b. al-'As, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 312 reports whose chains all start from 'Abd Allah b. 'Amr b. al-'As. All assessments of 'Abd Allah b. 'Amr b. al-'As.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Source text

“Dies wird die Sahifa sein, aus welcher sein Urenkel ʿAmr b. Shuʿejb (st. 120) sein Traditionsmaterial überlieferte, und aus diesem Grunde haben spätere Kritiker seine auf den Urgrossvater zurückgeführten Traditionsdaten nicht als vollgültig anerkannt.”

p. 10

“Man hat auf ihn insgesammt 700 Traditionen zurückgeführt, von denselben finden sich in beiden Sahihen nur 17, bei B. allein 8, bei M. allein 20, also von 700 Traditionen höchstens 45 von einigermaassen — wenn auch nur formell — erträglicher Glaubwürdigkeit.”

p. 195 n. 3

No published response has been linked yet.

Abu Musa al-Ash'ari

287 reports start from Abu Musa al-Ash'ari in the six books. Name forms used to identify them at the head of a chain: ابو موسي، ابو موسي الاشعري، ابي موسي، ابي موسي الاشعري

Shia hadith criticism

Minor · originating narrator criticised · Method: rijal assessment

al-Najmi (Adwa' 'ala al-Sahihayn) lists Abu Musa al-Ash'ari among narrators of the Two Sahihs whose reports he asks readers to weigh in light of what he describes as his hostility to 'Ali.

Muhammad Sadiq al-Najmi (n.d.) Adwa' 'ala al-Sahihayn, text from the OpenITI corpus (Zaydiyya0000454); pages as in that text, p. 101. Source

This assessment concerns Abu Musa al-Ash'ari, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 287 reports whose chains all start from Abu Musa al-Ash'ari. All assessments of Abu Musa al-Ash'ari.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Chapter 4 ('Evidence for the weakness of the Two Sahihs'), section 'Assessing the faith of some narrators of the Two Sahihs', where the author profiles narrators from whom al-Bukhari and Muslim took many reports.

Source text

ابو موسى الاشعري: هو احد رجال الصحيحين وقد ذكر له حفاظ اهل السنة واصحاب التراجم حسب ما تقتضيه عادتهم الكثير من المناقب والفضائل(2). ونقل البخاري عنه في صحيحه سبعة وخمسين (57) حديثا(3). وكان ابو موسى الاشعري من الد مبغضي الامام على (ع) واكثرهم عدا،

No published response has been linked yet.

Minor · originating narrator criticised · Method: rijal assessment

Khulasat 'Abaqat al-Anwar states that Abu Musa al-Ash'ari was held suspect in hadith by 'Umar b. al-Khattab (referring to the episode of the hadith on seeking permission).

Mir Hamid Husayn al-Lakhnawi (d. 1306 AH), abridged (1405 AH) Khulasat 'Abaqat al-Anwar, text from the OpenITI corpus (Shia001555), p. 3/245. Source

This assessment concerns Abu Musa al-Ash'ari, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 287 reports whose chains all start from Abu Musa al-Ash'ari. All assessments of Abu Musa al-Ash'ari.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Vol. 3, 'Rare episodes from the lives of the Companions', refuting al-Muzani's reading of the hadith 'my Companions are like the stars' (that every Companion is trustworthy in what he transmits); the author lists Companions whom other Companions called liars or held suspect.

Source text

أبو موسى الأشعري وكان أبو موسى الأشعري متهما في الحديث لدى عمر بن الخطاب، كما تقدم في هذا الكتاب.

No published response has been linked yet.

Samura b. Jundab

121 reports start from Samura b. Jundab in the six books. Name forms used to identify them at the head of a chain: سمره، سمره بن جندب

Shia hadith criticism

Substantive · narrator rejected in Shia assessment · Method: rijal assessment

Hashim Ma'ruf al-Hasani (Dirasat fi al-Hadith wa-l-Muhaddithin) reports that Mu'awiya paid Samura b. Jundab to attribute to the Prophet an interpretation of Qur'anic verses against 'Ali, citing this among Samura's misdeeds.

Hashim Ma'ruf al-Hasani (d. 1403 AH) (1398 AH) Dirasat fi al-Hadith wa-l-Muhaddithin, Beirut: Dar al-Ta'aruf li-l-Matbu'at; text from the OpenITI corpus, p. 103. Source

This assessment concerns Samura b. Jundab, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 121 reports whose chains all start from Samura b. Jundab. All assessments of Samura b. Jundab.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Chapter 3 ('On the Companions'), section 'The probity of the Companions' ('Adalat al-sahaba), arguing against the doctrine that all Companions are trustworthy narrators.

Source text

وحرض التابعين على الخروج لحرب الحسين بن علي (ع) وقتاله واعطاه معاوية خمسمئة الف درهم مقابل ان ينسب إلى الرسول (ص)

Dirasat fi al-Hadith wa-l-Muhaddithin, p. 103 · source text

No published response has been linked yet.

Substantive · narrator rejected in Shia assessment · Method: rijal assessment

Khulasat 'Abaqat al-Anwar states that Samura b. Jundab committed outright lying, citing al-Iskafi's report (via Ibn Abi al-Hadid) that Mu'awiya paid him to say that a verse was revealed about 'Ali.

Mir Hamid Husayn al-Lakhnawi (d. 1306 AH), abridged (1405 AH) Khulasat 'Abaqat al-Anwar, text from the OpenITI corpus (Shia001555), p. 3/262. Source

This assessment concerns Samura b. Jundab, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 121 reports whose chains all start from Samura b. Jundab. All assessments of Samura b. Jundab.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Vol. 3, 'Rare episodes from the lives of the Companions', refuting al-Muzani's reading of the hadith 'my Companions are like the stars' (that every Companion is trustworthy in what he transmits); the author lists Companions whom other Companions called liars or held suspect.

Source text

سمرة بن جندب وقد باع سمرة بن جندب دينه بدنياه وآثر العاجلة على الآخرة، إذ ارتكب الكذب الصريح وأتى بالبهتان العظيم،

No published response has been linked yet.

Substantive · narrator rejected in Shia assessment · Method: rijal assessment

Murtada al-'Askari (Ma'alim al-Madrasatayn) states that Samura b. Jundab, with 'Amr b. al-'As and Abu Hurayra, produced hadith to support Mu'awiya and narrated it from the Prophet.

Murtada al-'Askari (d. 1428 AH) (1410 AH / 1990) Ma'alim al-Madrasatayn, text from the OpenITI corpus (Shia001663), p. 2/52. Source

This assessment concerns Samura b. Jundab, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 121 reports whose chains all start from Samura b. Jundab. All assessments of Samura b. Jundab.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Vol. 2, on the influences that shaped the 'school of the caliphs' from Mu'awiya's time; followed by al-Mada'ini's account of Mu'awiya's letters to his governors.

Source text

فاستمد في هذا السبيل من بعض بقايا الصحابة ممن كان في دينه رقة، وفي نفسه ضعف من أمثال عمرو بن العاص، وسمرة بن جندب 1، وأبي هريرة. فاستجابوا له ووضعوا له من الحديث ما يساعده، ثم رووه عن رسول الله (ص).

No published response has been linked yet.

al-Mughira b. Shu'ba

96 reports start from al-Mughira b. Shu'ba in the six books. Name forms used to identify them at the head of a chain: المغيره، المغيره بن شعبه

Shia hadith criticism

Substantive · narrator rejected in Shia assessment · Method: rijal assessment

al-Najmi (Adwa' 'ala al-Sahihayn), relaying the Mu'tazili Abu Ja'far al-Iskafi, names al-Mughira b. Shu'ba among those Mu'awiya engaged to put hadith into circulation, and notes that al-Bukhari and Muslim narrate much from them.

Muhammad Sadiq al-Najmi (n.d.) Adwa' 'ala al-Sahihayn, text from the OpenITI corpus (Zaydiyya0000454); pages as in that text, p. 99. Source

This assessment concerns al-Mughira b. Shu'ba, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 96 reports whose chains all start from al-Mughira b. Shu'ba. All assessments of al-Mughira b. Shu'ba.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Chapter 4 ('Evidence for the weakness of the Two Sahihs'), section 'Assessing the faith of some narrators of the Two Sahihs', where the author profiles narrators from whom al-Bukhari and Muslim took many reports. The passage relays al-Iskafi's list (via Ibn Abi al-Hadid).

Source text

وعمرو بن العاص والمغيرة بن شعبة، ومن التابعين عروة بن الزبير(1). ويلاحظ القارئ المنصف ان هؤلاء الذين عدهم الاسكافي اعضا في مؤسسة معاوية لوضع الحديث كانوا ممن روى عنهم البخاري ومسلم احاديث كثيرة.

No published response has been linked yet.

Minor · originating narrator criticised · Method: rijal assessment

Khulasat 'Abaqat al-Anwar states that Abu Bakr and 'Umar each declined al-Mughira b. Shu'ba's report until another Companion confirmed it, and relays al-Iskafi's claim that he circulated reports against 'Ali at Mu'awiya's urging.

Mir Hamid Husayn al-Lakhnawi (d. 1306 AH), abridged (1405 AH) Khulasat 'Abaqat al-Anwar, text from the OpenITI corpus (Shia001555), p. 3/264. Source

This assessment concerns al-Mughira b. Shu'ba, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 96 reports whose chains all start from al-Mughira b. Shu'ba. All assessments of al-Mughira b. Shu'ba.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Vol. 3, 'Rare episodes from the lives of the Companions', refuting al-Muzani's reading of the hadith 'my Companions are like the stars' (that every Companion is trustworthy in what he transmits); the author lists Companions whom other Companions called liars or held suspect.

Source text

لقد اتهم أبو بكر المغيرة بن شعبة إذ رد خبره في ميراث الجدة حتى أخبره معه محمد بن مسلمة، ذكر ذلك جماعة منهم الغزالي في [المستصفى 1 135].

No published response has been linked yet.

Mu'awiya b. Abi Sufyan

61 reports start from Mu'awiya b. Abi Sufyan in the six books. Name forms used to identify them at the head of a chain: معاويه، معاويه بن ابي سفيان

Shia hadith criticism

Substantive · narrator rejected in Shia assessment · Method: rijal assessment

Khulasat 'Abaqat al-Anwar states that Mu'awiya urged followers to fabricate hadith and himself attributed falsehoods to the Prophet, citing a report in Ahmad and Abu Dawud.

Mir Hamid Husayn al-Lakhnawi (d. 1306 AH), abridged (1405 AH) Khulasat 'Abaqat al-Anwar, text from the OpenITI corpus (Shia001555), p. 3/265. Source

This assessment concerns Mu'awiya b. Abi Sufyan, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 61 reports whose chains all start from Mu'awiya b. Abi Sufyan. All assessments of Mu'awiya b. Abi Sufyan.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Vol. 3, 'Rare episodes from the lives of the Companions', refuting al-Muzani's reading of the hadith 'my Companions are like the stars' (that every Companion is trustworthy in what he transmits); the author lists Companions whom other Companions called liars or held suspect.

Source text

على أن معاوية نفسه كان يكذب على رسول الله صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم، فقد أخرج أحمد وأبو داود بإسنادهما عن أبي شيخ الهنائي

No published response has been linked yet.

Minor · originating narrator criticised · Method: rijal assessment

al-Amini (al-Ghadir) questions how far Mu'awiya, a late convert occupied with office and rule, could have learned the Sunna, before reviewing the hadith narrated from him in Ahmad's Musnad.

'Abd al-Husayn al-Amini (d. 1390 AH) (n.d.) al-Ghadir fi al-Kitab wa-l-Sunna wa-l-Adab, text from the OpenITI corpus (Zaydiyya0000142); volume/page as in that text, p. 10/352. Source

This assessment concerns Mu'awiya b. Abi Sufyan, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 61 reports whose chains all start from Mu'awiya b. Abi Sufyan. All assessments of Mu'awiya b. Abi Sufyan.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Vol. 10, introduction to 'A look at the hadith of Mu'awiya' (the 106 reports in Musnad Ahmad).

Source text

وإن حداثة عهد معاوية بالاسلام وأخذه بالروايات بعد كل ما قدمناه، وما كان يلهيه عن الاصاغة إليها طيلة أيامه من كتابة وإمارة وملوكية،

al-Ghadir fi al-Kitab wa-l-Sunna wa-l-Adab, p. 10/352 · source text

No published response has been linked yet.

Marwan b. al-Hakam

26 reports start from Marwan b. al-Hakam in the six books. Name forms used to identify them at the head of a chain: مروان، مروان بن الحكم

Sunni hadith criticism

Minor · originating narrator criticised · Method: rijal assessment

Ibn Hajar (Hady al-Sari) records that critics held against Marwan b. al-Hakam his killing of Talha at the Battle of the Camel and his armed bid for the caliphate.

Ibn Hajar al-'Asqalani (d. 852 AH) (1379 AH) Hady al-Sari, Muqaddimat Fath al-Bari, ed. Muhammad Fu'ad 'Abd al-Baqi and Muhibb al-Din al-Khatib, Beirut: Dar al-Ma'rifa; text from the OpenITI corpus, p. 443. Source

This assessment concerns Marwan b. al-Hakam, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 26 reports whose chains all start from Marwan b. al-Hakam. All assessments of Marwan b. al-Hakam.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Chapter 9, the list of al-Bukhari's narrators who were criticised, with Ibn Hajar's replies.

Source text

وإنما نقموا عليه أنه رمى طلحة يوم الجمل بسهم فقتله ثم شهر السيف في طلب الخلافة حتى جرى ما جرى

Hady al-Sari, Muqaddimat Fath al-Bari, p. 443 · source text
Published responses
  • Ibn Hajar al-'Asqalani (d. 852 AH), Hady al-Sari, Muqaddimat Fath al-Bari, p. 443: Ibn Hajar replies that Marwan may have seen the Prophet, that 'Urwa said Marwan was not suspected in hadith, that Sahl b. Sa'd narrated from him relying on his truthfulness, that the killing of Talha was based on an interpretation, and that al-Bukhari's reports from him date from before his conflict with Ibn al-Zubayr.

    يقال له رؤية فإن ثبتت فلا يعرج على من تكلم فيه وقال عروة بن الزبير كان مروان لا يتهم في الحديث

    Hady al-Sari, Muqaddimat Fath al-Bari, p. 443 · source text

Shia hadith criticism

Substantive · narrator rejected in Shia assessment · Method: rijal assessment

Khulasat 'Abaqat al-Anwar holds that Imam 'Ali b. al-Husayn would not have narrated from Marwan b. al-Hakam or Abu Hurayra, describing both in strongly negative terms.

Mir Hamid Husayn al-Lakhnawi (d. 1306 AH), abridged (1405 AH) Khulasat 'Abaqat al-Anwar, text from the OpenITI corpus (Shia001555), p. 4/248. Source

This assessment concerns Marwan b. al-Hakam, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 26 reports whose chains all start from Marwan b. al-Hakam. All assessments of Marwan b. al-Hakam.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Vol. 4, rejecting entries in Sunni biographical works that list Marwan b. al-Hakam among the teachers of 'Ali b. al-Husayn.

Source text

وكل مسلم يجل الإمام عليه السلام أن يروي عن هؤلاء ولا سيما أمثال مروان بن الحكم اللعين ابن اللعين، وأبي هريرة الكذاب...

No published response has been linked yet.

Minor · originating narrator criticised · Method: rijal assessment

Hashim Ma'ruf al-Hasani (Dirasat fi al-Hadith wa-l-Muhaddithin) notes that Marwan b. al-Hakam is the only Companion-era figure Sunni critics listed among al-Bukhari's criticised narrators, for killing Talha and taking up arms for the caliphate, and rejects Ibn Hajar's excuse.

Hashim Ma'ruf al-Hasani (d. 1403 AH) (1398 AH) Dirasat fi al-Hadith wa-l-Muhaddithin, Beirut: Dar al-Ta'aruf li-l-Matbu'at; text from the OpenITI corpus, p. 167. Source

This assessment concerns Marwan b. al-Hakam, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 26 reports whose chains all start from Marwan b. al-Hakam. All assessments of Marwan b. al-Hakam.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Chapter 5, section 'From the men of al-Bukhari', which reviews narrators in Sahih al-Bukhari who were criticised.

Source text

ولم يذكروا في عدادهم من الصحابة الا مروان بن الحكم لانه قتل طلحة في اعقاب واقعة الجمل وشهر السيف طلبا للخلافة على حد تعبير بعضهم واعتذر عنه جماعة منهم ابن حجر في مقدمة فتح الباري بانه كان متأولا فيه

Dirasat fi al-Hadith wa-l-Muhaddithin, p. 167 · source text

No published response has been linked yet.

'Amr b. al-'As

19 reports start from 'Amr b. al-'As in the six books. Name forms used to identify them at the head of a chain: عمرو بن العاص، عمرو بن العاصي

Shia hadith criticism

Substantive · narrator rejected in Shia assessment · Method: rijal assessment

al-Najmi (Adwa' 'ala al-Sahihayn) cites 'Ali's words on 'Amr b. al-'As to argue that 'Amr lied and that this bears on the worth of his reports in the Two Sahihs.

Muhammad Sadiq al-Najmi (n.d.) Adwa' 'ala al-Sahihayn, text from the OpenITI corpus (Zaydiyya0000454); pages as in that text, p. 103. Source

This assessment concerns 'Amr b. al-'As, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 19 reports whose chains all start from 'Amr b. al-'As. All assessments of 'Amr b. al-'As.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Chapter 4 ('Evidence for the weakness of the Two Sahihs'), section 'Assessing the faith of some narrators of the Two Sahihs', where the author profiles narrators from whom al-Bukhari and Muslim took many reports.

Source text

اكتفينا بذكر كلام للامام على (ع) بشان عمرو حتى يتجلى لنا كذبه وافتراه وبهتانه على امير المؤمنين الامام على (ع) وهذا الكلام العلوي يبدو وكانه لافتة تكشف لنا شخصية ابن العاص الدينية ودرجة اعتقاده ويبين مدى اهمية احاديثه التي اخرجها له الصحيحان

No published response has been linked yet.

Substantive · narrator rejected in Shia assessment · Method: rijal assessment

Khulasat 'Abaqat al-Anwar, relying on al-Iskafi, states that 'Amr b. al-'As was among the Companions Mu'awiya urged to put reports against 'Ali into circulation, and that he was habitually untruthful.

Mir Hamid Husayn al-Lakhnawi (d. 1306 AH), abridged (1405 AH) Khulasat 'Abaqat al-Anwar, text from the OpenITI corpus (Shia001555), p. 3/264. Source

This assessment concerns 'Amr b. al-'As, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 19 reports whose chains all start from 'Amr b. al-'As. All assessments of 'Amr b. al-'As.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Vol. 3, 'Rare episodes from the lives of the Companions', refuting al-Muzani's reading of the hadith 'my Companions are like the stars' (that every Companion is trustworthy in what he transmits); the author lists Companions whom other Companions called liars or held suspect.

Source text

وكان عمرو بن العاص من الصحابة الذين حرضهم معاوية بن أبي سفيان على وضع الأحاديث القبيحة في مولانا أمير المؤمنين عليه السلام، كما مر فيما سبق في عبارة الإسكافي. وكان قد تعود الكذب،

No published response has been linked yet.

Substantive · narrator rejected in Shia assessment · Method: rijal assessment

Murtada al-'Askari (Ma'alim al-Madrasatayn) states that 'Amr b. al-'As, Samura b. Jundab and Abu Hurayra responded to Mu'awiya by producing hadith to support him and narrating it from the Prophet.

Murtada al-'Askari (d. 1428 AH) (1410 AH / 1990) Ma'alim al-Madrasatayn, text from the OpenITI corpus (Shia001663), p. 2/52. Source

This assessment concerns 'Amr b. al-'As, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 19 reports whose chains all start from 'Amr b. al-'As. All assessments of 'Amr b. al-'As.

Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.

Curator's note

Vol. 2, on the influences that shaped the 'school of the caliphs' from Mu'awiya's time; followed by al-Mada'ini's account of Mu'awiya's letters to his governors.

Source text

فاستمد في هذا السبيل من بعض بقايا الصحابة ممن كان في دينه رقة، وفي نفسه ضعف من أمثال عمرو بن العاص، وسمرة بن جندب 1، وأبي هريرة. فاستجابوا له ووضعوا له من الحديث ما يساعده، ثم رووه عن رسول الله (ص).

No published response has been linked yet.

Recorded but not applied

These assessments concern Successors and later figures. Where a chain seems to stop at a Successor, the Companion is often named inside the text instead, so the reports that truly start from them cannot yet be read reliably from the chains. They are listed here and not counted in any level.