Hadith 5005
The Book of Hunting, Slaughter, and what may be Eaten · Food, drink and slaughter · Versions also placed under: Jihad and expeditions, Judgments and disputes, Marriage and family
Some issuesprovisionalWhy this level
Versions of this report
10 other versions found, in 4 books counting this one. Grouped automatically by shared wording or by the compiler's own cross-reference; not reviewed by a person. How versions are found.
- Sahih al-Bukhari 4216Some issuesprovisional
- Sahih al-Bukhari 6961Good qualityprovisional
- Sahih Muslim 3431Some issuesprovisional
- Sahih Muslim 3435Some issuesprovisional
- Sahih Muslim 3434Some issuesprovisional
- Sahih Muslim 5006Some issuesprovisional
- Sunan al-Nasa'i 3366Some issuesprovisional
- Sunan al-Nasa'i 4335Some issuesprovisional
- Sunan al-Nasa'i 4338Some issuesprovisional
- Sunan Ibn Majah 1961Some issuesprovisional
Similar wording
Reports that share wording with this one but are not grouped with it, for example the same saying from a different Companion.
Chain of transmission Automatic, not yet verified
The chain was separated from the text and its narrators matched to Ibn Hajar's Taqrib al-Tahdhib by a program. Matches can be wrong, especially for short names. Ibn Hajar's verdicts below are quoted from the matched entry. Automatic matches do not change the quality level; a narrator concern counts only after its match has been checked. How this works.
Chain: from Sahih Muslim's teacher back to the source
- يَحْيَى بْنُ يَحْيَى one matchيحيى بن يحيى بن بكر · Taqrib no. 7668 · highest praise (e.g. thiqa thiqa, thiqa hafiz) · «ثقة ثبت» · generation 10
Assessment by approach
Sunni hadith criticism Examined
This hadith is in Sahih Muslim. In Sunni hadith criticism the contents of Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim are regarded as authentic by consensus. This is a collection-level status, not a grade of this individual report; classical critiques of specific reports (for example by al-Daraqutni) are recorded as concerns. How this is handled.
Examined on 2026-11-16 against Classical critiques of the two Sahihs, version 1. No specific critique of this report was found. This covers only the sources listed; it is not a finding that no critique exists elsewhere.
Sources searched (5)
- Ibn Hajar al-'Asqalani, Hady al-Sari, chapter 8: the critiques of Sahih al-Bukhari by al-Daraqutni and others, with Ibn Hajar's answers (all 110 entries read)
- al-Daraqutni, al-Ilzamat wa-l-Tatabbu' (entries cited in Hady al-Sari and in al-Nawawi)
- Ibn 'Ammar al-Shahid, 'Ilal al-Ahadith fi Kitab al-Sahih li-Muslim, with al-Nawawi's answers in al-Minhaj
- Ibn Hazm, al-Muhalla bi-l-Athar, with al-Ihkam fi Usul al-Ahkam and al-Fisal: his rejections of reports in the six books
- al-Zarkashi, al-Ijaba li-Irad ma Istadrakathu 'A'isha 'ala al-Sahaba: every objection read
None of the classical critiques of the Sahihs in this source set criticises these reports of Sahih Muslim.
Checked by: AI (Claude), applying the site's records of these works; not yet reviewed by a person.
Shia hadith criticism Examined
Murtada al-'Askari argues that a prohibition of mut'a at Khaybar does not fit the historical record (citing Ibn al-Qayyim, al-Suhayli and Ibn Hajar), that someone invented this report through 'Ali's grandsons, and that it contradicts 'Ali's reported saying that but for 'Umar's prohibition of mut'a only the wretched would commit zina.
Murtada al-'Askari (d. 1428 AH) (1410 AH / 1990) Ma'alim al-Madrasatayn, text from the OpenITI corpus (Shia001663), p. 2/270. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Source text
غير أن أحدهم ابتكر رواية رواها عن حفيدي الامام على ابني محمد عن أبيهم محمد عن أبيه الإمام علي
No published response has been linked yet.
'Abd al-Husayn al-Amini lists Sunni scholars who said the Khaybar dating of the mut'a prohibition is unknown to historians or a narrator's error, and presents this report, the soundest one cited for abrogation, as contested; he describes the abrogation reports as inventions set against the established sunna and sound history.
'Abd al-Husayn al-Amini (d. 1390 AH) (n.d.) al-Ghadir fi al-Kitab wa-l-Sunna wa-l-Adab, text from the OpenITI corpus (Zaydiyya0000142); volume/page as in that text, p. 6/226. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Source text
هذا شأن أصح رواية أخرجته أئمة الحديث في النهي عن المتعة، والخطب في بقية مستند تلكم الأقوال أعظم
No published response has been linked yet.
Effect of this approach’s concerns on the level: none on their own (the level would still be Some issues without them).
Examined on 2026-11-16 against Shia-lens source set, version 1. The concerns found are listed above. This covers only the sources listed; it is not a finding that no critique exists elsewhere.
Sources searched (10)
- Muhammad Sadiq al-Najmi, Adwa' 'ala al-Sahihayn (text from the OpenITI corpus (Zaydiyya0000454); pages as in that text, n.d.)
- Hashim Ma'ruf al-Hasani (d. 1403 AH), Dirasat fi al-Hadith wa-l-Muhaddithin (Beirut: Dar al-Ta'aruf li-l-Matbu'at; text from the OpenITI corpus, 1398 AH)
- 'Abd al-Husayn Sharaf al-Din (d. 1377 AH), al-Nass wa-l-Ijtihad (ed. Abu Mujtaba; text from the OpenITI corpus (Zaydiyya0000161); pages as in that text, n.d.)
- 'Abd al-Husayn Sharaf al-Din (d. 1377 AH), al-Muraja'at (text from the OpenITI corpus (Zaydiyya0000199); pages as in that text, n.d.)
- 'Abd al-Husayn al-Amini (d. 1390 AH), al-Ghadir fi al-Kitab wa-l-Sunna wa-l-Adab (text from the OpenITI corpus (Zaydiyya0000142); volume/page as in that text, n.d.)
- Mir Hamid Husayn al-Lakhnawi (d. 1306 AH), abridged, Khulasat 'Abaqat al-Anwar (text from the OpenITI corpus (Shia001555), 1405 AH)
- Murtada al-'Askari (d. 1428 AH), Ahadith Umm al-Mu'minin 'A'isha (5th ed.; text from the OpenITI corpus (Shia001626), 1414 AH / 1994)
- Murtada al-'Askari (d. 1428 AH), Ma'alim al-Madrasatayn (text from the OpenITI corpus (Shia001663), 1410 AH / 1990)
- al-Shaykh al-Tusi (d. 460 AH), Tahdhib al-Ahkam (Najaf: Dar al-Kutub al-Islamiyya; text from the OpenITI corpus, 1959)
- al-Shaykh al-Tusi (d. 460 AH), al-Istibsar fima ukhtulifa min al-akhbar (Najaf: Dar al-Kutub al-Islamiyya; text from the OpenITI corpus, 1957)
Two concerns: al-'Askari (input passage) and al-Amini (found in the full text of al-Ghadir 6/226, outside the input passages).
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Historical-critical method Not yet examined
No published academic study has been recorded for this hadith yet. This is not a finding that there are none.
Known study not yet checked. This report is discussed in the work(s) below, which could not be opened for this site yet, so this lens stays "not yet examined" for it.
- Joseph Schacht (1950), The Origins of Muhammadan Jurisprudence, pp. 266-267 (see also p. 175) (no openly licensed copy could be used; needs a library or licensed copy)