Hadith 5097
The Book of Sacrifices · Food, drink and slaughter · Versions also placed under: Fasting, Prayer
Some issuesprovisionalWhy this level
Versions of this report
2 other versions found, in 3 books counting this one. Grouped automatically by shared wording or by the compiler's own cross-reference; not reviewed by a person. How versions are found.
Similar wording
Reports that share wording with this one but are not grouped with it, for example the same saying from a different Companion.
Chain of transmission Automatic, not yet verified
The chain was separated from the text and its narrators matched to Ibn Hajar's Taqrib al-Tahdhib by a program. Matches can be wrong, especially for short names. Ibn Hajar's verdicts below are quoted from the matched entry. Automatic matches do not change the quality level; a narrator concern counts only after its match has been checked. How this works.
Chain: from Sahih Muslim's teacher back to the source
- عَبْدُ الْجَبَّارِ بْنُ الْعَلاَءِ one match
- سُفْيَانُ matched from contextسفيان بن عيينة بن أبي · Taqrib no. 2451 · highest praise (e.g. thiqa thiqa, thiqa hafiz) · «ثقة حافظ» · generation 8Also in Rijal al-Tusi, no. 2925: سفيان بن عيينة بن أبي عمران الهلالي، مولاهم، أبو محمد الكوفي، أقام بمكة.…
- الزُّهْرِيُّ matched from contextمحمد بن مسلم بن عبيد · Taqrib no. 6296 · verdict not read · generation 4
- أَبِي عُبَيْدٍ matched from context
Assessment by approach
Sunni hadith criticism Examined
This hadith is in Sahih Muslim. In Sunni hadith criticism the contents of Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim are regarded as authentic by consensus. This is a collection-level status, not a grade of this individual report; classical critiques of specific reports (for example by al-Daraqutni) are recorded as concerns. How this is handled.
Ibn 'Ammar objected that attributing 'Ali's report on eating sacrificial meat after three days to the Prophet ﷺ is not preserved in Ibn 'Uyayna's narration, citing al-Humaydi, to whom Sufyan said he did not remember it as the Prophet ﷺ's words.
Ibn 'Ammar al-Shahid (d. 317 AH) (2012) 'Ilal al-Ahadith fi Kitab al-Sahih li-Muslim b. al-Hajjaj, text from the OpenITI corpus (ShamAY0034174), p. 60. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
Review: notes are informational
Source text
قال أبو الفضل: ورفع هذا الحديث عندي غير محفوظ في حديث ابن عيينة.
- al-Nawawi, al-Minhaj Sharh Sahih Muslim, 13/128: al-Nawawi reports Qadi 'Iyad and al-Daraqutni that the attribution to the Prophet ﷺ via Sufyan is defective and an error by 'Abd al-Jabbar, while it is sound from al-Zuhri through others, and concludes that the text is sound in any case. Position: grants a defect in this route or a slip in its wording, but holds the report sound.
هذا كلام الدارقطني والمتن صحيح بكل حال والله أعلم
al-Daraqutni objected that 'Abd al-Jabbar b. al-'Ala' erred in giving Ibn 'Uyayna's version of 'Ali's ban on keeping sacrificial meat beyond three days as the Prophet ﷺ's words, since al-Humaydi, Ibn al-Madini, Ahmad and others give it from Ibn 'Uyayna as 'Ali's own statement; he adds that the marfu' version is sound from al-Zuhri through others.
al-Daraqutni (d. 385 AH) (1985) al-Ilzamat wa-l-Tatabbu', ed. Muqbil b. Hadi al-Wadi'i, 2nd ed., Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-'Ilmiyya; text from the OpenITI corpus, no. 138. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
Review: notes are informational
Source text
وهذا مما وهم فيه عبد الجبار لأن الحميدي وعلي بن المديني والقعنبي وأحمد بن حنبل وإسحاق بن راهويه
- al-Nawawi, al-Minhaj Sharh Sahih Muslim, 13/128: al-Nawawi quotes al-Qadi 'Iyad and al-Daraqutni on the defect in Sufyan's route and replies that the text is sound in any case. Position: grants a defect in this route or a slip in its wording, but holds the report sound.
هذا كلام الدارقطني والمتن صحيح بكل حال والله أعلم
Effect of this approach’s concerns on the level: none on their own (the level would still be Some issues without them).
Examined on 2026-11-16 against Classical critiques of the two Sahihs, version 1. The concerns found are listed above. This covers only the sources listed; it is not a finding that no critique exists elsewhere.
Sources searched (5)
- Ibn Hajar al-'Asqalani, Hady al-Sari, chapter 8: the critiques of Sahih al-Bukhari by al-Daraqutni and others, with Ibn Hajar's answers (all 110 entries read)
- al-Daraqutni, al-Ilzamat wa-l-Tatabbu' (entries cited in Hady al-Sari and in al-Nawawi)
- Ibn 'Ammar al-Shahid, 'Ilal al-Ahadith fi Kitab al-Sahih li-Muslim, with al-Nawawi's answers in al-Minhaj
- Ibn Hazm, al-Muhalla bi-l-Athar, with al-Ihkam fi Usul al-Ahkam and al-Fisal: his rejections of reports in the six books
- al-Zarkashi, al-Ijaba li-Irad ma Istadrakathu 'A'isha 'ala al-Sahaba: every objection read
The critiques are listed as concerns on each report's page.
Checked by: AI (Claude), applying the site's records of these works; not yet reviewed by a person.
Shia hadith criticism Not yet examined
No narrator assessments from Shia rijal works or cited critiques have been recorded for this hadith yet. This is not a finding that there are none.
Historical-critical method Not yet examined
No published academic study has been recorded for this hadith yet. This is not a finding that there are none.