Hadith 4460
The Book of Legal Punishments · Crime and punishment
Some issuesprovisionalWhy this level
Versions of this report
5 other versions found, in 5 books counting this one. Grouped automatically by shared wording or by the compiler's own cross-reference; not reviewed by a person. How versions are found.
Chain of transmission Automatic, not yet verified
The chain was separated from the text and its narrators matched to Ibn Hajar's Taqrib al-Tahdhib by a program. Matches can be wrong, especially for short names. Ibn Hajar's verdicts below are quoted from the matched entry. Automatic matches do not change the quality level; a narrator concern counts only after its match has been checked. How this works.
Chain: from Sahih Muslim's teacher back to the source
- أَحْمَدُ بْنُ عِيسَى one match
- ابْنُ وَهْبٍ matched from contextعبد الله بن وهب بن · Taqrib no. 3694 · highest praise (e.g. thiqa thiqa, thiqa hafiz) · «ثقة حافظ» · generation 9
- عَمْرٌو matched from context
- بُكَيْرِ بْنِ الأَشَجِّ matched from contextAlso in Rijal al-Tusi, no. 1079: بكير بن عبد الله بن الأشج.…
Assessment by approach
Sunni hadith criticism Examined
This hadith is in Sahih Muslim. In Sunni hadith criticism the contents of Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim are regarded as authentic by consensus. This is a collection-level status, not a grade of this individual report; classical critiques of specific reports (for example by al-Daraqutni) are recorded as concerns. How this is handled.
al-Daraqutni noted that 'Amr b. al-Harith's chain Bukayr > Sulayman b. Yasar > Ibn Jabir > his father > Abu Burda b. Niyar for 'no more than ten lashes except in a hadd' is contradicted by al-Layth and Sa'id b. Abi Ayyub, who omit 'his father', and by Muslim b. Abi Maryam ('from one who heard the Prophet ﷺ'), though he himself judged 'Amr's version correct because he is reliable and adds a narrator.
al-Daraqutni (d. 385 AH) (1985) al-Ilzamat wa-l-Tatabbu', ed. Muqbil b. Hadi al-Wadi'i, 2nd ed., Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-'Ilmiyya; text from the OpenITI corpus, no. 92. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
Ibn Hajar gives no explicit verdict here; he describes what each compiler included. Since al-Daraqutni himself judged 'Amr's chain correct, 'rejects' is a reading of the entry, not a stated view. The Hady text repeats 'fa-lam yaqula 'an abihi' at the end, apparently a textual slip; not quoted. Review: settled at review: Ibn Hajar gives no verdict in this entry, so the position is recorded as no_verdict
Source text
وقول عمرو صحيح والله أعلم لأنه ثقة وقد زاد رجلا
وقد خالفه الليث بن سعد وسعيد بن أبي أيوب فروياه عن يزيد بن أبي حبيب عن بكير فلم يقولا عن أبيه
- Ibn Hajar, Hady al-Sari, chapter 8, no. 100, p. 380: Ibn Hajar replies that al-Bukhari gave all the variant chains except Usama's, while Muslim gave only 'Amr b. al-Harith's. Position: records the objection without ruling on it.
قلت أخرج البخاري الأوجه كلها إلا رواية أسامة واقتصر مسلم على حديث عمرو بن الحارث عن بكير
Effect of this approach’s concerns on the level: they are why the level is Some issues; without them the level would be Good quality.
Examined on 2026-11-16 against Classical critiques of the two Sahihs, version 1. The concerns found are listed above. This covers only the sources listed; it is not a finding that no critique exists elsewhere.
Sources searched (5)
- Ibn Hajar al-'Asqalani, Hady al-Sari, chapter 8: the critiques of Sahih al-Bukhari by al-Daraqutni and others, with Ibn Hajar's answers (all 110 entries read)
- al-Daraqutni, al-Ilzamat wa-l-Tatabbu' (entries cited in Hady al-Sari and in al-Nawawi)
- Ibn 'Ammar al-Shahid, 'Ilal al-Ahadith fi Kitab al-Sahih li-Muslim, with al-Nawawi's answers in al-Minhaj
- Ibn Hazm, al-Muhalla bi-l-Athar, with al-Ihkam fi Usul al-Ahkam and al-Fisal: his rejections of reports in the six books
- al-Zarkashi, al-Ijaba li-Irad ma Istadrakathu 'A'isha 'ala al-Sahaba: every objection read
The critiques are listed as concerns on each report's page.
Checked by: AI (Claude), applying the site's records of these works; not yet reviewed by a person.
Shia hadith criticism Not yet examined
No narrator assessments from Shia rijal works or cited critiques have been recorded for this hadith yet. This is not a finding that there are none.
Historical-critical method Not yet examined
No published academic study has been recorded for this hadith yet. This is not a finding that there are none.