Hadith 2198
Sales and Trade · Trade and finance · Versions also placed under: Zakat and charity
Some issuesWhy this level
Versions of this report
3 other versions found, in 3 books counting this one. Grouped automatically by shared wording or by the compiler's own cross-reference; not reviewed by a person. How versions are found.
- Sahih al-Bukhari 1488Some issuesprovisional
- Sahih Muslim 3978Some issues
- Sunan al-Nasa'i 4526Good qualityprovisional
Similar wording
Reports that share wording with this one but are not grouped with it, for example the same saying from a different Companion.
Chain of transmission Automatic, not yet verified
The chain was separated from the text and its narrators matched to Ibn Hajar's Taqrib al-Tahdhib by a program. Matches can be wrong, especially for short names. Ibn Hajar's verdicts below are quoted from the matched entry. Automatic matches do not change the quality level; a narrator concern counts only after its match has been checked. How this works.
Chain: from Sahih al-Bukhari's teacher back to the source
- عَبْدُ اللَّهِ بْنُ يُوسُفَ one matchعبد الله بن يوسف التنيسي · Taqrib no. 3721 · highest praise (e.g. thiqa thiqa, thiqa hafiz) · «ثقة متقن» · generation 10
- مَالِكٌ matched from contextمالك بن أنس بن مالك · Taqrib no. 6425 · highest praise (e.g. thiqa thiqa, thiqa hafiz) · «إمام» · generation 7
- حُمَيْدٍ matched from context
- أَنَسِ بْنِ مَالِكٍ one matchأنس بن مالك بن النضر · Taqrib no. 565 · verdict not read
Assessment by approach
Sunni hadith criticism Examined
This hadith is in Sahih al-Bukhari. In Sunni hadith criticism the contents of Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim are regarded as authentic by consensus. This is a collection-level status, not a grade of this individual report; classical critiques of specific reports (for example by al-Daraqutni) are recorded as concerns. How this is handled.
al-Daraqutni objected that in Malik's version from Humayd from Anas the words 'If God withholds the fruit, by what would one of you take his brother's property?' are attributed to the Prophet ﷺ, whereas Isma'il b. Ja'far, Ibn al-Mubarak and others give them as Anas's words.
al-Daraqutni (d. 385 AH) (1985) al-Ilzamat wa-l-Tatabbu', ed. Muqbil b. Hadi al-Wadi'i, 2nd ed., Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-'Ilmiyya; text from the OpenITI corpus, no. 198. Source
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
Ibn Hajar neither refutes nor explicitly endorses the idraj claim; he says 'والأمر في مثل هذا قريب'. 'accepts' is a judgement call. bukhari-1488 (Qutayba > Malik > Humayd) lacks the disputed sentence and is not listed. The response quote is on p. 359; the critique quote on p. 358. Review: settled at review: Ibn Hajar gives no verdict in this entry, so the position is recorded as no_verdict
Source text
قال: وقد خالف مالكا جماعة منهم إسماعيل بن جعفر وابن المبارك وهشيم ومروان ويزيد بن هارون وغيرهم قالوا فيه قال أنس: أرأيت إن منع الله الثمرة.
خالف مالكا جماعة منهم إسماعيل بن جعفر وبن المبارك وهشيم ومروان بن معاوية ويزيد بن هارون وغيرهم قالوا فيه قال أنس أرأيت إن منع الله الثمرة
- Ibn Hajar, Hady al-Sari, chapter 8, no. 29, p. 360: Ibn Hajar notes that Abu Hatim, Abu Zur'a, Ibn Khuzayma and others had already claimed interpolation (idraj) here, records Mu'tamir's uncertainty whether Anas said it or reported it from the Prophet ﷺ, and calls the matter a minor one. Position: records the objection without ruling on it.
قلت سبق الدارقطني إلى دعوى الإدراج في هذا الحديث أبو حاتم وأبو زرعة الرازيان وبن خزيمة وغير واحد من أئمة الحديث
Effect of this approach’s concerns on the level: they are why the level is Some issues; without them the level would be Good quality.
Shia hadith criticism Examined
Khulasat 'Abaqat al-Anwar states that Anas b. Malik lied in the episode of the roasted bird (Hadith al-Tayr) and concealed testimony about Ghadir when asked by 'Ali.
Mir Hamid Husayn al-Lakhnawi (d. 1306 AH), abridged (1405 AH) Khulasat 'Abaqat al-Anwar, text from the OpenITI corpus (Shia001555), p. 3/258. Source
This assessment concerns Anas b. Malik, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 2,063 reports whose chains all start from Anas b. Malik. All assessments of Anas b. Malik.
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Curator's note
Vol. 3, 'Rare episodes from the lives of the Companions', refuting al-Muzani's reading of the hadith 'my Companions are like the stars' (that every Companion is trustworthy in what he transmits); the author lists Companions whom other Companions called liars or held suspect.
Source text
أنس بن مالك لقد كذب أنس بن مالك في قضية الطير المشوي، كما هو ظاهر كل الظهور على من راجع مجلد (حديث الطير) من كتابنا.
No published response has been linked yet.
Effect of this approach’s concerns on the level: none on their own (the level would still be Some issues without them).
Historical-critical method Examined
Goldziher (1884) cites a dialogue ascribed to Abu Hanifa in which he would set aside his own opinion for any Companion's view except those of Abu Hurayra, Anas b. Malik and Samura b. Jundab.
Ignaz Goldziher (1884) Die Ẓâhiriten: ihr Lehrsystem und ihre Geschichte, Leipzig: Otto Schulze, p. 79. Source
This assessment concerns Anas b. Malik, the person this report starts from. It applies to all 2,063 reports whose chains all start from Anas b. Malik. All assessments of Anas b. Malik.
Checked by: AI (Claude), reading the source text; not yet reviewed by a person.
Source text
“mit Ausnahme des Abu Hurejra, Anas b. Mālik und Samura b. Gundab”
No published response has been linked yet.